The Difference Between Marketplace and E-commerce: Which One is More Profitable?

The Difference Between Marketplace and E-commerce: Which One is More Profitable?

In this digital era, online businesses are growing rapidly. Almost everyone can now sell products or services with just a few clicks. However, before starting, one fundamental question often arises: Is it better to sell on a marketplace or build your own e-commerce?

Many beginner entrepreneurs assume that marketplaces and e-commerce are the same, whereas they have fundamental differences that can significantly impact your business strategy.

If you want to understand the difference between a marketplace and e-commerce and determine which one is more profitable, this article will help you find the answer.

Why is it Important to Understand the Difference Between Marketplace and E-commerce?

Before diving into online business, it is essential to understand how each business model works. Here are some reasons why you should know the differences:

• More Precise Business Strategy – Each model has its own advantages and disadvantages. Knowing which one suits your product and target market can help you avoid major mistakes.
• Operational Efficiency and Cost Management – Marketplaces and e-commerce have different operational systems and cost structures. Choosing the wrong platform can hinder your business growth.
• Control and Branding – If you want to build your own brand, understanding the difference between marketplaces and e-commerce is crucial to avoid missteps.

What is a Marketplace and E-commerce?

In the online business world, the difference between a marketplace and e-commerce often confuses many people. While both are used for digital buying and selling, they have very different concepts.

Let’s break them down one by one so you can understand which is best for your business.

1. Marketplace: A Buying and Selling Platform with Multiple Sellers

A marketplace is a digital platform that connects multiple sellers with buyers in one place. In a marketplace, a business owner can sell their products alongside thousands or even millions of other sellers within a system managed by a third party.

Popular Marketplaces in Indonesia:

• Shopee – A platform offering various product categories, from fashion and electronics to daily necessities.
• Tokopedia – A C2C and B2C-based marketplace that allows individuals and small businesses to sell easily.
• Bukalapak – One of Indonesia’s largest marketplaces that supports sellers across various business sectors.

How a Marketplace Works:

• Easy Registration – You only need to create an account and upload products to start selling.
• Centralized Transaction System – The marketplace handles payments, transaction verification, and, in some cases, product shipping.
• High Competition – With many sellers on one platform, you must compete in pricing and marketing strategies to attract buyers.
• Commission and Advertising Fees – Most marketplaces charge a commission on each transaction and offer paid advertising features to increase product visibility.

A marketplace is suitable for those who want to start selling quickly without building their own website, but they must be prepared for intense competition.

2. E-commerce: A Sales Website with Full Control

E-commerce is a digital business model where a company or individual sells products directly to customers through their own website. Unlike a marketplace, which is a third-party platform, e-commerce is fully controlled by its owner.

Popular E-commerce Platforms:

• Zalora – A fashion-focused e-commerce site that manages its own products as well as other brands.
• IKEA Indonesia – The official online shopping platform for IKEA, selling furniture and household products.
• Independent Business Websites – Such as online stores owned by SMEs or specific brands using platforms like WooCommerce, Shopify, or Magento.

How E-commerce Works:

• Building Your Own Brand – With an e-commerce website, you can create a unique and exclusive brand identity.
• Full Control Over Products and Pricing – You can set prices, marketing strategies, and customer experience independently.
• Higher Initial Costs – Building e-commerce requires a larger investment for website development, hosting, and promotion.
• Independent Marketing – Unlike marketplaces that already have high traffic, e-commerce owners must attract customers through SEO, digital ads, or social media.

E-commerce is a better choice for long-term business and those who want to avoid dependency on marketplaces.

3. Basic Comparison Between Marketplace and E-commerce

Key Differences Between Marketplace and E-commerce

After understanding the definitions of each, it’s time to discuss the marketplace and e-commerce differences in more depth. Choosing the right platform is not just about where you want to sell but also how you want to run your business in the long term.

Here are the main differences between marketplaces and e-commerce that you should know before starting an online business.

1. Ownership and Product Management

Marketplace:

• A marketplace is a platform that hosts multiple sellers in one place.
• Marketplace owners like Shopee, Tokopedia, or Bukalapak only provide infrastructure, while the products come from various merchants or online stores.
• As a seller in a marketplace, you do not have full control over the platform’s system, such as sales policies, payment methods, or shipping regulations.

E-commerce:

• E-commerce is usually managed by a single entity or brand.
• E-commerce websites like Zalora, IKEA, or stores using WooCommerce and Shopify only sell products from one business owner or brand.
• By having your own e-commerce, you have full control over all business aspects, from products and pricing to marketing strategies.

2. Costs and Commissions

Marketplace:

• Registration is usually free or has a very low initial cost.
• However, marketplaces charge a commission on each transaction (ranging from 2% to 10% or more, depending on the platform).
• There are additional fees such as service fees, advertising costs, and logistics fees (if using the marketplace’s shipping service).
• Although it seems cheaper at first, in the long run, commission fees and advertising costs can reduce your profits.

E-commerce:

• Creating e-commerce requires a larger initial investment since you have to build your own website.
• Costs include hosting, domain, website design, and payment system management.
• There are no transaction fees, so profits from each sale are maximized.
• Requires independent marketing strategies such as SEO, paid ads (Google Ads, Facebook Ads), or organic marketing through social media.

3. Reach and Audience

Marketplace:

• Marketplaces have high traffic because millions of people are already used to shopping on platforms like Shopee and Tokopedia.
• The major advantage of a marketplace is that you can immediately reach potential buyers without extensive marketing.
• However, since there are thousands of competitors in one product category, price competition is very tight, forcing many sellers to offer large discounts to attract customers.

E-commerce:

• E-commerce may not have high traffic instantly, but it can build a stronger customer relationship in the long run.
• With effective digital marketing strategies like SEO, email marketing, and social media, e-commerce owners can develop a loyal customer base.
• E-commerce focuses more on brand engagement, where customers trust stores with a stronger identity and more personalized customer service.

4. Control Over User Experience

Marketplace:

• Marketplaces have rules and policies that all sellers must follow.
• Store appearance and transaction systems are pre-determined by the platform, with minimal customization options.
• Customers are more loyal to the marketplace than to your brand, as they often switch stores based on the best prices.
• If the marketplace changes its policies, such as increasing commissions or limiting certain features, sellers must adapt or lose business opportunities.

E-commerce:

• With e-commerce, you have full control over website design, payment systems, and customer service.
• You can create a unique experience that differentiates you from competitors, such as exclusive offers, attractive designs, and customer loyalty programs.
• Customer trust is higher since transactions are conducted directly with your brand rather than a third party.

Read Also: Powerful Tips to Increase Your Instagram Engagement

Advantages and Disadvantages of Each Platform

After understanding the differences between marketplaces and e-commerce, the next step is to weigh the advantages and disadvantages of each platform.

Both marketplaces and e-commerce have benefits that can be leveraged, but they also have limitations that need to be considered before choosing the right business strategy.

1. Advantages and Disadvantages of Marketplaces

Marketplaces are the choice of many entrepreneurs due to their ease of starting an online business. However, behind their advantages, there are some limitations that need to be considered.

Advantages of Marketplaces

Easy to Start

• No need to create your own website or handle technical aspects.
• Simply register, upload products, and you can start selling immediately.

Large Existing Audience

• Marketplaces like Shopee, Tokopedia, and Bukalapak already have millions of daily visitors.
• You don’t have to worry about generating traffic like in e-commerce.

Lower Initial Costs

• No website development or payment system management fees.
• Initial capital can be focused on product stock and marketplace advertising.

Integrated Payment and Shipping Systems

• Marketplaces provide secure payment systems trusted by customers.
• Many marketplaces offer logistics features that simplify the shipping process.

Disadvantages of Marketplaces

Limited Control Over Business

• You must follow marketplace rules, including pricing structures, discount policies, and commission systems.
• If the marketplace changes its policies, you must adapt or risk losing sales.

High Competition and Price Wars

• Thousands of other sellers offer similar products with competitive pricing.
• You have to compete through large discounts and low-price strategies to attract customers.

Sales Commission and Advertising Costs

• Every transaction is subject to a commission by the marketplace, which can reduce profits.
• To increase product visibility, you need to advertise within the marketplace, which can add to operational costs.

2. Advantages and Disadvantages of E-commerce

If you want full control over your online business, e-commerce is the right choice. However, e-commerce also comes with challenges that need to be considered.

Advantages of E-commerce

Full Control Over Business

• You can set your own prices, create promotions according to strategy, and fully control customer experience.
• No need to follow third-party rules like in marketplaces.

Better Customer Relationships

• With your own website, you can collect customer data, conduct retargeting, and build customer loyalty through email marketing or membership programs.
• Customers buy not just because of low prices but because they trust your brand.

Maximum Profit Without Commission

• No marketplace commission deductions, allowing higher profits from each transaction.
• You only need to pay for hosting, domain, and marketing, which can be more cost-effective in the long run.

Strong Branding

• With e-commerce, you can build an exclusive brand that does not blend with thousands of competitors on a single platform.
• You can use unique designs, logos, and personalized features to create a distinctive customer experience.

Disadvantages of E-commerce

Higher Initial Investment

• Creating an e-commerce website requires costs for hosting, domain, and website development.
• You also need to build your own payment system so customers can transact easily.

Requires Independent Marketing Strategies

• Unlike marketplaces that already have high traffic, e-commerce must attract customers through SEO, digital ads, or social media marketing.
• Without a good marketing strategy, e-commerce can lack visitors and struggle to grow.

More Complex Management

• E-commerce owners must manage various technical aspects such as website maintenance, customer data security, and payment system integration.
• If technical issues arise, you need to resolve them yourself or hire an expert.

Also Take Advantage of Our Services: SEO Services

Which One is More Profitable?

After understanding the differences between marketplaces and e-commerce, a big question arises: Which one is more profitable?

The answer depends on your business situation. Each model has its own advantages and challenges, and the best choice depends on your business scale, long-term goals, and the strategies you implement.

Here is a detailed evaluation to help you determine the platform that best suits your business needs.

1. Evaluating the Right Business Situations for Each Platform

Marketplace is Suitable For:

New or Beginner Businesses

• If you are just starting to sell and do not have a large budget, a marketplace can be an ideal choice.
• You don’t need to worry about digital infrastructure and can focus directly on selling products.

Businesses Targeting the Mass Market

• If your products fall into fast-selling categories (such as fashion, electronics, or daily necessities), marketplaces offer access to millions of potential customers.

Entrepreneurs Who Don’t Want to Manage a Website

• If you want to focus solely on selling without managing a website, payment system, or technical infrastructure, a marketplace is more practical.

E-commerce is Suitable For:

Businesses That Want to Build Their Own Brand

• If you want full control over customer experience, pricing, and store appearance, e-commerce is the best choice.
• Large brands like Zalora and IKEA use the e-commerce model to build identity and exclusivity.

Businesses with a Long-Term Model

• If your goal is a long-term business with higher profit margins, e-commerce is more profitable because there are no transaction commissions like in marketplaces.
• You can use SEO and digital marketing strategies to attract loyal customers.

Premium or Exclusive Products or Services

• If you sell custom, handmade, or exclusive products, e-commerce allows you to control pricing without engaging in price wars like in marketplaces.

2. Considerations for Business Scale, Long-Term Goals, and Business Model

When choosing between a marketplace and e-commerce, you need to consider the following key factors:

Business Scale

• Small businesses or individuals are more suited to start in marketplaces because costs are lower and market access is broader.
• Medium to large-scale businesses are better suited for e-commerce to be more independent and have greater profits.

Long-Term Goals

• If your goal is simply to sell products without building a brand, a marketplace is a faster and easier option.
• If you want a growing business with loyal customers, e-commerce provides greater flexibility.

Marketing Strategy

• Marketplaces already have high traffic, but you must compete with many sellers.
• E-commerce requires independent marketing strategies such as SEO, social media, and digital ads to succeed.

Long-Term Profitability

• Marketplaces charge a commission on every transaction, which can reduce profit margins over time.
• E-commerce may require a higher initial cost, but its profits are greater because you do not pay commissions to third parties.

3. Tips for Choosing the Right Platform for Your Business Needs

If you are still unsure about choosing between a marketplace and e-commerce, here are some practical tips to help you decide:

Use a Marketplace if:

• You want to start selling immediately with minimal capital.
• You don’t want to manage a website or payment system.
• Your products have high competition and require a large volume of sales.
•  You are prepared for price wars and transaction commissions from the platform.

Use E-commerce if:

• You want to build a more exclusive brand and have full control over your business.
•  You want to avoid commission fees and maximize long-term profits.
•  You are ready to manage your own marketing strategy and build traffic through SEO, ads, or social media.
•  You want to have your own customer database to increase loyalty and retargeting.

Hybrid Solution: Using Both

Some businesses use a combination of marketplaces and e-commerce to get the best results.

For example:

• Use a marketplace to reach new customers and test products.
• Build e-commerce to attract loyal customers and enhance branding.

With a hybrid strategy, you can optimize the benefits of both platforms and get the best results for your business.

Conclusion: 

After understanding the differences between marketplaces and e-commerce, you now know that there is no absolute right or wrong answer in choosing an online business platform. Everything depends on your business needs, goals, and strategies.

A marketplace is the best option if:

•  You want to start a business quickly with minimal capital.
•  You want to reach a broad audience without building your own traffic.
•  You don’t want to deal with website management, payment systems, and shipping.
•  You are ready to face tight competition and price wars.

E-commerce is more profitable if:

• You want full control over business and branding.
•  You want to maximize long-term profits without marketplace commissions.
•  You want to build stronger and more loyal customer relationships.
•  You are ready to invest in digital marketing, SEO, and managing your own website.

Combining Marketplaces and E-commerce: The Ideal Hybrid Strategy

Many successful businesses use both simultaneously to maximize benefits.

• Use a marketplace as an entry point to gain initial customers.
• Build e-commerce as a long-term strategy for stronger branding and higher profits.